Hey, yoga teachers! Here's a scenario: You're teaching a class. A fellow teacher, who teaches at the very same studio, attends your class. He or she sets up in the front row. He or she even makes a request before class begins. Wishing to be accommodating, you alter your sequence plan to work the pose into your class so that your fellow teacher can get the practice he or she needs. No problem.
A few minutes into class, you notice that this teacher/student is modifying every pose. No, not modifying -- alternating. This person is substituting different poses for the poses you are teaching. In fact, as you go on, you notice he or she is doing a completely different practice altogether, summarily ignoring your instruction. Did I mention he/she is in the front row for all of your students to see, students who are aware that this person in the front row ignoring the teacher is also a teacher, a clear and living example? Not cool.
As a teacher, I emphasize to all my students in one way or another that their practice is always their own. I make it clear that they may modify in whatever way they need to or take rest at any time and rejoin the class when ready. I mean these things when I say them. It is my belief that the progress of any serious student should lead them beyond their teacher to find that the only true teacher is the practice itself. I realize that this may not be good for business, but since I'm not exactly rolling in the dough as it is, I don't really care. It's the truth.
As a student, when I attend classes, and especially when I attend classes in studios where I also teach, I try to give the teacher my utmost attention and respect. Why? Not only because I am there to learn and perhaps experience the practice in a different way, but also because I know that I am a beacon. Students will look to me, as a YOGA TEACHER in the FRONT ROW, as an example, both in terms of behavior and practice. I know that it can be difficult, when one has an established personal practice, to let go of our attachment to the way it has to be, to surrender the precious time that we have to nourish ourselves to the hands of a teacher and colleague who may or may not interpret the practice of asana in the same way. But if we refuse to soften our grasp on the form of our practice, what's the point of attending a class in the first place? For that matter, what is the point of the practice at all if we are not receptive to experience?
I do not wish to shame anyone and I don't feel personally injured by this teacher's actions. At the time, I found the display more amusing than aggravating and I absolutely respect this person's prerogative to serve their own needs, but the experience stuck in my side all week and came up this morning during meditation. My ego wants to interpret this teacher's actions as an insult. It wants to validate itself with misery. But I choose to step back and let the ego throw it's little fit, kicking and screaming on the floor in an empty room. Let the needy cries of the small-self fall on deaf ears. I simply proffer the questions above for whomever it may concern in hopes that we may all take one step further along the path.
A few minutes into class, you notice that this teacher/student is modifying every pose. No, not modifying -- alternating. This person is substituting different poses for the poses you are teaching. In fact, as you go on, you notice he or she is doing a completely different practice altogether, summarily ignoring your instruction. Did I mention he/she is in the front row for all of your students to see, students who are aware that this person in the front row ignoring the teacher is also a teacher, a clear and living example? Not cool.
As a teacher, I emphasize to all my students in one way or another that their practice is always their own. I make it clear that they may modify in whatever way they need to or take rest at any time and rejoin the class when ready. I mean these things when I say them. It is my belief that the progress of any serious student should lead them beyond their teacher to find that the only true teacher is the practice itself. I realize that this may not be good for business, but since I'm not exactly rolling in the dough as it is, I don't really care. It's the truth.
As a student, when I attend classes, and especially when I attend classes in studios where I also teach, I try to give the teacher my utmost attention and respect. Why? Not only because I am there to learn and perhaps experience the practice in a different way, but also because I know that I am a beacon. Students will look to me, as a YOGA TEACHER in the FRONT ROW, as an example, both in terms of behavior and practice. I know that it can be difficult, when one has an established personal practice, to let go of our attachment to the way it has to be, to surrender the precious time that we have to nourish ourselves to the hands of a teacher and colleague who may or may not interpret the practice of asana in the same way. But if we refuse to soften our grasp on the form of our practice, what's the point of attending a class in the first place? For that matter, what is the point of the practice at all if we are not receptive to experience?
I do not wish to shame anyone and I don't feel personally injured by this teacher's actions. At the time, I found the display more amusing than aggravating and I absolutely respect this person's prerogative to serve their own needs, but the experience stuck in my side all week and came up this morning during meditation. My ego wants to interpret this teacher's actions as an insult. It wants to validate itself with misery. But I choose to step back and let the ego throw it's little fit, kicking and screaming on the floor in an empty room. Let the needy cries of the small-self fall on deaf ears. I simply proffer the questions above for whomever it may concern in hopes that we may all take one step further along the path.
What a great posting! You are SO right about this and I have been on the receiving end of this as well. When I was a new teacher it bothered me. Now it amuses me like you mentioned and I have let it go. I love to take other classes to experience another teachers ways, to hear different cues different wording and above all to not fall into the personal practice rut. Keeps one humble!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Heidi. It's nice to know I'm not alone on this. And I completely agree with you; I love taking classes because it keeps me out of a rut. Even when I don't jive with the teacher's style, I always come away from the class with something valuable to add to my practice.
ReplyDeleteI've seen this happen before in classes, although I haven't had a teacher do this in any class that I've taught before (thank goodness...because I probably would've said something to the teacher during class). Personally, I think if a teacher wants to do his/her own practice, they don't need to be going to someone else's led class. I can't imagine walking into someone's class and just doing my own thing in the front row. It's rude to the teacher of the class...but could also be harmful for new students who could get the wrong impression that it's okay to just ignore the teacher and move however they want in class.
ReplyDeleteLike Heidi, I also like to attend a variety of yoga classes to learn new styles of teaching or different verbal cues. Sometimes it's just fun to be taught in a new way. On a side note, I attended my first Kundalini class today...wow, totally different from my regular practice...but fun. But I always approach each teacher with a degree of respect for their method and style of teaching.
Hi Arkie - Yeah... I really don't understand it. I may modify or intensify a pose in a class to suit my own needs on any given day, but I certainly wouldn't take up a spot in someone's class with no intention to practice the teacher's sequence... not to mention my responsibility as a teacher at that studio to be a safe example for students.
ReplyDeleteKundalini, eh? I know so little about it. What's it like?
That's just bad manners.
ReplyDeleteI found his/her behavior to be very un-cool and disrespectful. Isn't the point of going to someone's else class is to learn and open yourself to a new perspective? She should have practiced at her house. However, I think you did the right thing and you did it gracefully. Hopefully one day he/she will realize that she has been isolating and closing his/herself to the people and the practice. She needs to learn how to be a student before she can become a good teacher.
ReplyDeleteIt's not just teachers... I recently watched a fellow student show up 10 minutes late, do her own practice in the front row, then interrupt the teacher to ask for a drop-back assist (to which he very calmly but firmly said "not today") before packing up while the rest of us were in savasana. Some people just have no idea that their behavior can impact the people around them.
ReplyDeleteV - I hope that's all it is.
ReplyDeleteLinh - My thoughts exactly.
Liska - Yikes! Interrupted the teacher AND left during Savasana? NOT okay.
As someone new to the practice of yoga, I often look to more experienced yogis in the class to see if I am doing something correctly, especially if I know that one is also a teacher. This could be so confusing! Did you approach said teacher after class to discuss this?
ReplyDeleteHi Dottie - I did not approach the teacher after class, he/she snuck out pretty quickly without saying thank you or goodbye (also rude behavior for a colleague, in my opinion). I don't want to hound anyone or make anyone feel guilty. I just hope he/she reads this and maybe considers the questions I've asked. To summarize: what is the purpose of the practice if we are not open to receive, experience, and learn?
ReplyDeleteWhoa, seriously? A teacher? I've had students I didn't know do this on a few occasions (it's very strange to begin with, but then usually after class they'd approach me and tell me how much they enjoyed class--what?!?) I don't understand it either, but it's clearly not your deal to figure out. If that happens again I do think you should approach that person, at least for the sake of the other students.
ReplyDeleteRachel - Ha! I've had students do the same thing! Just do their own practice in class, not listen to any of my alignment cues, and then tell me what a great teacher I am after class. It's strange, but I guess it reinforces the fact that yoga is very much an internal, individualized practice. We have no way of knowing what's really going on in the minds of our students, which is why I hesitate to say anything to people appear to be simply ignoring me. But I do think, with a fellow teacher, it's a slightly different situation. We have responsibilities to each other and to the students, whether or not we are actively teaching at the time.
ReplyDelete